For Profit vs Not for Profit Schools

For Profit vs Not for Profit Schools
Published
Written by
What are the advantages and/or disadvantages of a for profit versus a not for profit school? Is one kind of school better than the other?
Private schools are generally set up in one of two ways: as a for profit or a not for profit entity. What are the advantages and/or disadvantages of a for profit versus a not for profit school? Is one kind of school better than the other?

For Profit Schools
A for profit school is controlled by the owner. It is usually in business to make money or turn a profit. Parents pay for the school's services just as though they were customers. Examples of this sort of school include Le Rosey in Switzerland, Sylvan Learning Centers, the Nobel Schools, as well as thousands of small nursery and primary schools. The school can be incorporated or a sole proprietorship or some other form of ownership.

The advantage is that the owner truly calls the shots and controls everything. If the parents do not like what is being offered, they can take their children elsewhere. Parental input may be sought and even entertained, but the final decisions and control rest with the owner.

Not For Profit Schools
Most private schools seek 501(c)(3) status from the IRS once they have incorporated. This is the non-profit status which  exempts the entity from federal, state and local taxes. It also permits the school to accept contributions which are in turn tax-deductible to the extent provided by law.

Some schools are set up so that parents own shares in the corporation. The ownership formulae vary but most seem to depend on the number of children enrolled in the school.

Most not for profit schools will have an active board of trustees. The trustees are the mechanism by which the school governed. Depending on how the charter is set up, its powers will be quite extensive. A headmaster at such a school is hired by the board of trustees. This governance mechanism allows the school to outlive its founder, and, all things being equal, last for generations. Examples of this sort of school include Kent School which was founded by Father Frederick Herbert Sill in 1906 and Exeter Academy which was founded by John Phillips in 1781.
 
And, no, one kind of school is not any better than another. A school's success is measured intrinsically by its teaching, not its governance.

Additional Resources [+]
{"http://www.privateschoolreview.com/articles/93":{"comments":{"data":[]}}}

Classical Christian Schools
Classical Christian schools combine strict adherence to Christian beliefs with classical principles of education.

Top Roman Catholic Boarding Schools Top Roman Catholic Boarding Schools
These Roman Catholic boarding schools offer good value, great educations and a faith-based community experience.

comments powered by Disqus

Recent Articles:

About Girls' Schools: In Their Words
About Girls' Schools: In Their Words
Published April 15, 2013
Here are a dozen or so girls' schools' public thoughts about themselves and their missions.

Make Summer a Special Time! Make Summer a Special Time!
If you have children in private school, then you are most likely looking at three months, perhaps even longer, which you must fill with activities of one kind or another during the long summer break.

Are You Liable? Are You Liable?
Is your DEL key about to get gaveled? It doesn't matter whether you teach in a public or private school setting. You expose yourself to legal risks every single day on the job.

  • More articles: Choosing a Private School, Paying For It, Pre-elementary, High School Issues, Jobs in Private Schools
  • RSS/XML Feed RSS

    Why Private School:

    Kinds of Schools

    The various kinds and types of private schools

    • Top Roman Catholic Boarding Schools Top Roman Catholic Boarding Schools
      These Roman Catholic boarding schools offer good value, great educations and a faith-based community experience.
    • For Profit vs Not for Profit Schools For Profit vs Not for Profit Schools
      What are the advantages and/or disadvantages of a for profit versus a not for profit school? Is one kind of school better than the other?
    • Waldorf Schools
      Waldorf schools offer a well thought out approach to K-12 education.
    • Teaching Boys Teaching Boys
      Why teach boys in a single sex setting? The answer to this question and several others here.
    • Schools for Gifted Children Schools for Gifted Children
      Teaching gifted children requires deft handling. These children need intellectual and sensory stimulation. But they also need guidance and careful nurturing so that they grow up handling their special gifts and themselves appropriately.
    • Read more articles (23)

    Most Popular Articles: