Private and Public Schools Compared

Updated June 28, 2016 |
Private and Public Schools Compared
How many students attend private school? What are some of the main differences between these two modes of K-12 education? This table sets out the basic characteristics of private and public schools so that you can compare them.
This table will help you see at a glance how private schools compare with public schools. Use it to explore issues and to help answer questions which you have about private schools. A list of resources with supporting data and information is given at the end of the table.

 

  Private Schools Public Schools
Administration The local support staff manage the day to day operations of each private school. Most private schools are stand-alone entities responsible for their own fund-raising and all other aspects of running their businesses. Local school and district layers of administrative staff support the day to day operations of all schools within a specific school district.
Admissions Selective. Students must meet whatever admissions standards are set. These standards focus on the candidate's ability to do the academic work as well as other factors. Students must meet residency and age requirements. Students are admitted without regard to academic ability.
Arts All kinds of arts programs are essential components of a private school education. You will find orchestras, bands and choirs as part of the performing arts offerings. Fine arts and theater are also part of most programs. Arts programs are generally considered extras in a public school budget. They are usually one of the first areas of expense to be cut when savings must be found in budgets.
Census Approximately 4.9 million students were projected to attend private K-12 schools for the academic year 2015-2016. Aproximately 50.1 million students were projected to attend public K-12 schools for the academic year 2015-2016.
Class Size Private high schools generally have small classes, with 12-15 students the norm. Many prep schools use Harkness tables which seat 10 students at an oval table. The teacher sits at the table with his students. This approach encourages maximum student participation in the lesson. Class sizes in the primary grades typically run from 15-18 students per class. Depending on the staffing in a local school, public high schools can have as many as 25-35 students, or even more, per class. Class size will vary depending on the subject. Most high school classrooms have desks for the students. Elementary grade class sizes usually are in the 30-35 student range. 
College Preparation Most private high schools over a college prep curriculum based on Advanced Placement courses. Some high schools offer the International Baccalaureate Diploma Program. Public high schools offer AP courses although the number of courses offered is limited by teaching resources and budgets. A handful of public high schools offer the IB Diploma Program.
Curriculum Private schools develop their own curricula. They teach the subjects they wish to teach as well as meeting the state minimums. They use a variety of assessment methods to determine how a child is performing. Public schools must teach what the state and the district board tell them to teach. In addition, they must prepare students for state assessment testing on a regular basis.
Discipline Zero tolerance is the norm in most private schools. Students are governed by contract law and can be dismissed for cause. Most private schools have codes of conduct which govern all aspects of student and community life. Discipline is always subject to due process and an individual student's rights under the Constitution. It can take weeks, even months, to resolve issues in order to implement and observe due process.
Extracurricular Activities Private schools usually mount a wide offering of extracurricular activities depending on the kind of school and its program. Private schools subscribe to the philosophy of educating the whole child. Extracurricular activities offer opportunities for personal growth and social development. Clubs and activities are considered extras. They tend to be reduced or cut when budgets are cut back.
Funding Sources Private schools rely on tuition and other fees, gifts and endowments for their operating revenues. They are generally tax-exempt as well. Public school districts derive their revenue from local property taxes and some state and federal aid to meet their budgeted expenses. Some fund-raising activities occur in public schools, although they tend to be restricted to projects.
Parental Involvement Parents are expected to be involved and supportive of their child's education. Most private schools consider a child's education to be a partnership of three: school, student and parents. Parents are expected to be involved and supportive of their child's education.
Policy and Management Private schools typically are tax-exempt, not for profit entities run by a board of directors or trustees. They operate under the terms of their charter as they see fit. A small number of Public schools are managed by an elected school boards. Their meetings are governed by a host of state and local regulations and laws.
Single Sex Education Whether a private school is a boys' school or a girls' school is a decision made by the board of trustees. Single sex education has some very strong advocates. While there are some public single sex schools, they can be controversial depending on the feelings of the local populace.
Sports Sports are an integral part of a private school program. Coaching a sport is part of a private school teacher's responsibilities. Sports programs tend to be reduced or cut when budgets are cut back. Public school teachers are not required to coach a sport unless specified in their union contract.
Teachers Private school teachers do not belong to a union. They do not have to be certified and licensed though most private school teachers are certified and licensed. Public school teachers belong to a union except teachers in many charter schools. Public school teachers must be certified and licensed by the state in which they teach.
Transportation Parents drive their children to day school or pay for private carriers to take care of transportation. Transportation is provided by the district.
Uniforms and Dress Codes Most private schools have a dress code. Many schools require students to wear uniforms. Dress codes and uniforms are controversial in the public school arena. Whether they exist depends on the stance of the local school board's policies.

 

Questions? Contact me via Twitter. @privateschl


Additional Resources [+]
comments powered by Disqus
5 Things Not To Like About Private School
5 Things Not To Like About Private School
Being an Expat and Educating Your Children Abroad
Being an Expat and Educating Your Children Abroad
Recent Articles
December 07, 2016
In addition to complying with all the usual admissions requirements, international students must also obtain a student visa. Here are five tips to help you navigate the admissions process.
November 30, 2016
SSAT and ISEE scores are one part of the total picture which most private school admissions staff review. These standardized tests reveal what you have learned in key mastery areas.
November 21, 2016
What is really important in choosing a private school? Ranks? Academics? Financial aid? Sports programs? Arts programs? One of these criteria doesn't matter. The others do.
Why Private School

ABOUT PRIVATE SCHOOLS

An in depth look at private schools, including history, a comparison to public education, and a glimpse of what's being taught. Learn about the benefits of attending private school, to both students and parents. Explore private schools options when living abroad, and debunk many of the myths regarding private school education.