St. James Lutheran School vs. Sacred Heart Catholic School
Should you attend St. James Lutheran School or Sacred Heart Catholic School? Visitors to our site frequently compare these two schools. Compare their rankings, scores, reviews and more to help you determine which school is the best choice for you.
School Overview
Top Rankings
St. James Lutheran School ranks among the top 20% of private schools in Wisconsin for:
Category
Attribute
Student Body
Sacred Heart Catholic School ranks among the top 20% of private schools in Wisconsin for:
Category
Attribute
Affordability
Sports offered
School History
Overview
St. James Lutheran School serves 285 students in grades Prekindergarten-8, is a member of the Other religious school association(s).
The student:teacher of St. James Lutheran School is 20:1 and the school's religious affiliation is Lutheran Church Missouri Synod.
A school where a faith-filled journey with Jesus guides us as a trusting team, integrating Catholic values into a high-quality academic program and forming lifelong learners who live their faith. Discover the Heart of Education at Sacred Heart Catholic School!Looking for a school that nurtures your child's mind, spirit, and character? At Sacred Heart Catholic School, we offer more than just academics-we offer a community rooted in faith, service, and excellence. Why Choose Sacred Heart? Faith-Centered Learning: From preschool through 8th grade, students grow in their understanding of God while developing strong moral values and a sense of purpose.
Academic Excellence: With small class sizes (average 12 students) and a 13:1 student-teacher ratio, your child receives personalized attention in a challenging and supportive environment.
Inclusive & Welcoming: We embrace families of all faiths and backgrounds, creating a diverse and respectful school culture.
Affordable Tuition: Sacred Heart ranks among the most affordable private schools in Wisconsin-and we offer scholarships, tuition assistance, and School Choice options to make it even more accessible.
Well-Rounded Development: From STEM programs to student council, and multiple sports including volleyball, basketball, and cheer, your child will thrive both inside and outside the classroom.
Grades Offered
PK-8
NS-8
Blue Ribbon School
No
No
Offers Post-Graduate Year
No
n/a
Learning Difference Programs
Yes
Yes
Learning Programs Supported
n/a
Speech, language, adhd, add
Year Founded
n/a
1889
Students Body
Total Students
285 students
130 students
Student Body Type
Co-ed
Co-ed
% Students of Color
14%
47%
Students by Grade
Students by Grade
Nursery Students
-
12
Pre-K Students
68
14
Kindergarten Students
24
21
Grade 1 Students
25
12
Grade 2 Students
40
12
Grade 3 Students
24
11
Grade 4 Students
24
8
Grade 5 Students
26
15
Grade 6 Students
20
7
Grade 7 Students
17
9
Grade 8 Students
17
9
Academics and Faculty
Total Classroom Teachers
14 teachers
10 teachers
% Faculty with Advance Degree
16%
3%
Average Class Size
21
12
Teacher : Student Ratio
1:20
1:13
Classroom Dress Code
Casual
Casual
(Polo and Khaki pants on Mass days)
(Polo and Khaki pants on Mass days)
Finances and Admission
Admission Deadline
None / Rolling
None / Rolling
Tuition Cost
n/a
$2,225
Tuition Notes
n/a
Tuition cost differs based on grade of enrollment and parish membership, and includes the parish subsidy. Please contact our Admissions Director to allow us to work with your family and share our scholarships, discounts, subsidies, credits, and tuition assistance options. We are also a School Choice/Voucher school now. Applications accepted from February-April.
% on Financial Aid
n/a
60%
Average Financial Aid Grant
n/a
$800
Acceptance Rate
n/a
96%
Admissions Director
n/a
Autumne Gee
Sports
Total Sports Offered
5
11
Extracurriculars
Total Extra-curric.Total Extracurriculars
n/a
2
Extra-curric.Extracurriculars
n/a
Athletic Programs, Student Council