Buffalo Suburban Christian Academy Photo

Best Lancaster Private Schools (2026)

For the 2026 school year, there are 4 private schools serving 787 students in Lancaster, NY (there are 6 public schools, serving 4,904 public students). 14% of all K-12 students in Lancaster, NY are educated in private schools (compared to the NY state average of 14%).
The top-ranked private schools in Lancaster, NY include St. Marys Elementary School and St. Marys High School.
75% of private schools in Lancaster, NY are religiously affiliated (most commonly Catholic and Seventh Day Adventist).

Top-Ranked Lancaster Private Schools (2026)

School
Location
Quick Facts
St. Marys Elementary School
(Catholic)
(1)
2 Saint Marys Hl
Lancaster, NY 14086
(716) 683-2112
Gr: PK-8 | 351 students Avg. class size: 20 students Sports: 9 Tuition listed
St. Marys High School
St. Marys High School Photo
(Catholic)
142 Laverack Ave
Lancaster, NY 14086
(716) 683-4824
Gr: 9-12 | 416 students Avg. class size: 15 students Sports: 17 | Extracurrculars: 19 Tuition listed
Buffalo Suburban Christian Academy
Buffalo Suburban Christian Academy Photo
(Seventh Day Adventist)
5580 Genesee St
Lancaster, NY 14086
(716) 580-0763
Gr: K-8 | 20 students
Walden Avenue KinderCare
Daycare / Preschool
3970 Walden Ave
Lancaster, NY 14086
(716) 309-5900
Gr: NS-PK

Overview

This Town (Lancaster)
This State (NY)
# Schools
4 Schools

Student Body:

# Students
787 Students
424,936 Students
% Average Students of Color
24%
39%

Academics and Faculty:

# Teachers
63 Teachers
41,601 Teachers
Average Student-Teacher Ratio
12:1
10:1
% Average Faculty w/Advanced Degree
90%
76%
Average Class Size
18 students
15 students
Average Number of AP Courses
7 courses
11 courses
Average SAT score
1000
(Out of 1600)
1248

Tuition and Acceptance Rate:

Average Yearly Tuition Cost
$7,325
$22,391
Average % on Financial Aid
90%
33%

Students by Ethnicity:

0.57
0.59
# American Indian Students
2 Students
949 Students
% American Indian Students
n/a
n/a
# Asian Students
26 Students
18,401 Students
% Asian Students
3%
5%
# Hispanic Students
49 Students
33,760 Students
% Hispanic Students
6%
8%
# Black Students
39 Students
33,699 Students
% Black Students
5%
8%
# White Students
479 Students
253,643 Students
% White Students
61%
60%
# Hawaiian Students
n/a
538 Students
% Hawaiian Students
n/a
n/a
# Two or more races Students
n/a
n/a
% of Two or more races Students
n/a
n/a
# Others Students
192 Students
81,687 Students
% of Others Students
25%
19%
All Ethnic Groups

Extracurriculars and Sports:

Average Number of Extracurriculars
19 extracurriculars
13 extracurriculars
Average Number of Sports
13 sports
7 sports

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top-ranked private schools in Lancaster, NY?
The top-ranked private schools in Lancaster, NY include St. Marys Elementary School and St. Marys High School.
How many private schools are located in Lancaster?
4 private schools are located in Lancaster.
What percentage of students in Lancaster go to private school?
14% of all K-12 students in Lancaster are educated in private schools (compared to the NY state average of 14%).
What percentage of private schools are religiously affiliated in Lancaster?
75% of private schools in Lancaster are religiously affiliated (most commonly Catholic and Seventh Day Adventist).

Recent Articles

How to Stress-Test a Private School Budget Before Enrolling
How to Stress-Test a Private School Budget Before Enrolling
Learn how to stress-test a private school budget before enrolling and avoid financial surprises that can affect your family's long-term plans.
When “Affordable Private School” Means Fewer Services
When “Affordable Private School” Means Fewer Services
Learn what families may sacrifice when choosing an affordable private school and how to evaluate whether lower tuition still delivers long-term value.
Voucher Eligibility Fine Print Parents Miss
Voucher Eligibility Fine Print Parents Miss
Learn the hidden voucher eligibility rules that can affect school choice decisions and how parents can avoid common application mistakes.