Inspired by the vision and spirit of our founder, St. John Neumann, St. Mary's Elementary School today continues the mission which was Neumann's: to provide excellence in Catholic education for the children of Lancaster, Depew and surrounding areas.
Indeed, from the founding days of St. John Neumann in 1836 through the present, St. Mary's Elementary School has left to our community a strong legacy of graduates who have demonstrated a deep sense of love of God, country, neighbor and family.
Today, St. Mary's Elementary School continues its commitment to foster in our students the ability to be visible examples of the Gospel, especially by being of service to others.
We see as our mission the development of the complete Christ-like person-academically, spiritually, physically, morally, socially and emotionally.
Moreover, through the constant support, presence and commitment of our families, combined with the dedicated efforts and care of our professional faculty and staff, we seek to develop students who combine an enthusiasm for learning and growth with a true respect for and dedication to the values of our community.
Thus, the children educated at St. Mary's Elementary School will take with them into the future the faith, intelligence, responsibility, self-discipline, integrity and compassion necessary to both serve and lead their fellow human beings.
Quick Facts (2026)
- Top-Ranked NY School
- Grades: Prekindergarten-8
- Enrollment: 351 students
- Yearly Tuition: $4,650
- Average class size: 20 students
- Application Deadline: None / Rolling
- Source: Verified school update
Top Rankings
St. Marys Elementary School ranks among the top 20% of private schools in New York for:
Category
Attribute
Affordability
Student Body
School History
School Overview
School Membership(s)School Assoc.
Religious Affiliation
Grades Offered
Grades Prekindergarten-8
Year Founded
1847
School Calendar
Student Body
Total Students
351 students
Student Body Type
Co-ed
% Students of Color
39%
State avg.: 40%
Students by Grade
Academics and Faculty
Total Classroom Teachers
34 teachers
Student-Teacher Ratio
10:1
National avg.: 13:1
Average Class Size
20 students
Number of AP/Advanced Courses
2 courses
Classroom Dress Code
Casual
School Uniform
Tuition and Acceptance Rate
Admission Deadline
None / Rolling
Yearly Tuition Cost
Tuition Notes
Tuition rates are based on the various chosen options
Admissions Director
Jayne OGrady
Admissions Associate
Amanda Kuhn
Sports
Total Sports Offered
9 sports
School Notes
- Inspired by the vision and spirit of our founder, St. John Neumann, St. Mary's Elementary School today continues the mission which was Neumann's: to provide excellence in Catholic education for the children of Lancaster, Depew and surrounding areas. Indeed, from the founding days of St. John Neumann in 1836 through the present, St. Mary's Elementary School has left to our community a strong legacy of graduates who have demonstrated a deep sense of love of God, country, neighbor and family. Today, St. Mary's Elementary School continues its commitment to foster in our students the ability to be visible examples of the Gospel, especially by being of service to others. We see as our mission the development of the complete Christ-like person-academically, spiritually, physically, morally, socially and emotionally. Moreover, through the constant support, presence and commitment of our families, combined with the dedicated efforts and care of our professional faculty and staff, we seek to develop students who combine an enthusiasm for learning and growth with a true respect for and dedication to the values of our community. Thus, the children educated at St. Mary's Elementary School will take with them into the future the faith, intelligence, responsibility, self-discipline, integrity and compassion necessary to both serve and lead their fellow human beings.
Source: Verified school update
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does St. Marys Elementary School cost?
St. Marys Elementary School's tuition is approximately $4,650 for private students.
What schools are St. Marys Elementary School often compared to?
St. Marys Elementary School is often viewed alongside schools like Our Lady Of The Blessed Sacrament School by visitors of our site.
What sports does St. Marys Elementary School offer?
St. Marys Elementary School offers 9 interscholastic sports: Baseball, Basketball, Bowling, Cross Country, Soccer, Softball, Swimming, Track and Field and Volleyball.
What is St. Marys Elementary School's ranking?
St. Marys Elementary School ranks among the top 20% of private schools in New York for: Least expensive tuition, Largest student body and Oldest founding date.
When is the application deadline for St. Marys Elementary School?
The application deadline for St. Marys Elementary School is rolling (applications are reviewed as they are received year-round).
School Reviews
5 5/6/2018
Sending my children to this school was the best decision I ever made. I feel my kids are totally prepared for high school
Endorse St. Marys Elementary School. Endorsements should be a few sentences in length. Please include any comments on:
- Quality of academic programs, teachers, and facilities
- Availability of music, art, sports and other extracurricular activities
- Academic or athletic awards
Recent Articles
Navigating Private School Finances 2026
Essential 2026 guide for parents on private school costs, financial aid, and planning strategies.
Preparation for Standardized Tests & College Admissions 2026
A 2026 guide for private school test prep and college admissions strategies, with insights, trends, and best practices for families and educators.
Mental Health & Wellness Support in Private Schools: Key Questions for Parents
Discover essential questions about mental health & wellness support in private schools before enrolling, with 2026 updates for informed decisions.
