Private School Review - Established 2003

Best New York Mennonite Private High Schools (2026-27)

For the 2026-27 school year, there are 3 mennonite private high schools serving 136 students in New York. You can also find more religiously affiliated schools in New York.
The average acceptance rate is 90%, which is higher than the New York private high school average acceptance rate of 75%.

Quick Facts (2026-27)

  • # Private Schools: 3
  • # Students Served: 136

Quick Facts (2026-27)

  • # Private Schools: 3
  • # Students Served: 136

Mennonite Private High Schools in New York (2026-27)

Map of Followers Of Jesus School
Followers Of Jesus School
Gr: 1-12 | 41 students
Avg. class size: 8 students
Extracurriculars: 1
Mennonite
3065 Atlantic Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11208
(718) 235-5493
(3)
View Profile
Map of River Valley Mennonite School
River Valley Mennonite School
Gr: K-12 | 82 students
Avg. class size: 7 students
Sports: 4 | Extracurriculars: 2
Alternative School (Mennonite)
5473 State Route 410
Castorland, NY 13620
(315) 493-0187
View Profile
Map of Silver Lake Mennonite School
Silver Lake Mennonite School
Gr: 1-10 | 13 students
Mennonite
6286 Burke Hill Rd
Perry, NY 14530
(585) 798-1208
View Profile

Frequently Asked Questions

How many mennonite private high schools are located in New York?
3 mennonite private high schools are located in New York.
3
Private Schools
136
Students
$3,775
Avg. Tuition
80%
Students of Color
7:1
Student-Teacher Ratio

Recent Articles

When Your Child Outpaces the Private School Curriculum
When Your Child Outpaces the Private School Curriculum
Learn what parents can do when a child finishes private school coursework early, including acceleration, curriculum compacting, advanced classes, enrichment, and signs the school needs a new plan.
How Much Teacher Access Does Your Child Get?
How Much Teacher Access Does Your Child Get?
Learn how to evaluate teacher access at private schools, including extra-help time, advising, communication, academic support, and the questions families should ask before choosing a school today.
When a Private School Teacher Leaves Midyear
When a Private School Teacher Leaves Midyear
When a private school teacher leaves midyear, parents need clear answers. Learn what schools should do, what children may experience, and when a departure signals deeper concerns.

Quick Links

SCHOOL SEARCH TOOLS:
SCHOOL BY TYPE (NY):
OPEN-HOUSES & JOBS:
PUBLIC & BOARDING SCHOOLS:
PRIVATE SCHOOL DATA: