For the 2025 school year, there are 24 private schools serving 1,180 students in Mifflin County, PA (there are 10 public schools, serving 4,591 public students). 20% of all K-12 students in Mifflin County, PA are educated in private schools (compared to the PA state average of 14%).
The top ranked private schools in Mifflin County, PA include Belleville Mennonite School, Coffee Run School, and Sacred Heart Of Jesus School.
The average acceptance rate is 100%, which is higher than the Pennsylvania private school average acceptance rate of 81%.
Top Ranked Mifflin County Private Schools (2025)
School
Location
Grades
Students
4105 Front Mountain Road
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 935-2184
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 935-2184
Grades: PK-12
| 250 students
Coffee Run School
(Amish)
820 Coffee Run Rd
Reedsville, PA 17084
(717) 994-5480
Reedsville, PA 17084
(717) 994-5480
Grades: 1-8
| 21 students
Sacred Heart Of Jesus School
(Catholic)
110 N Dorcas St
Lewistown, PA 17044
(171) 724-8535
Lewistown, PA 17044
(171) 724-8535
Grades: K-5
| 74 students
Barrville Amish School
(Amish)
E Back Mountain Rd
Reedsville, PA 17084
(717) 667-4207
Reedsville, PA 17084
(717) 667-4207
Grades: 1-8
| 23 students
Beth Elementary Christian Day School
(Mennonite)
41 Schoolhouse Rd
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 483-6511
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 483-6511
Grades: 1-12
| 64 students
C/o Marlin Stoltzfus, School Board Director
(Mennonite)
234 Little Brick Rd
Mc Veytown, PA 17051
(717) 899-6933
Mc Veytown, PA 17051
(717) 899-6933
Grades: 1-8
| 33 students
61 Huey St
Allensville, PA 17002
(717) 483-9983
Allensville, PA 17002
(717) 483-9983
Grades: Inquire with school
| 9 students
Living Springs Christian School
(Mennonite)
500 Ridge Rd
Mc Veytown, PA 17051
(717) 899-6248
Mc Veytown, PA 17051
(717) 899-6248
Grades: 1-8
| 47 students
101 N Beech Street
Burnham, PA 17009
(717) 242-1481
Burnham, PA 17009
(717) 242-1481
Grades: PK-12
| 109 students
Orchard Side School
(Amish)
70 Rolling Hill Ln
Allensville, PA 17002
(717) 483-6720
Allensville, PA 17002
(717) 483-6720
Grades: 1-8
| 25 students
Pleasant View School
(Mennonite)
2392 Front Mountain Rd
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 250-5477
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 250-5477
Grades: 2-8
| 22 students
Rock Haven Christian School
(Mennonite)
138 Peachey Rd
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 935-2766
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 935-2766
Grades: K-8
| 37 students
1075 Coffee Run Rd
Reedsville, PA 17084
Reedsville, PA 17084
Grades: Inquire with school
| 4 students
Valley View Christian School
(Mennonite)
120 Applehouse Rd
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 935-5183
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 935-5183
Grades: 1-12
| 77 students
Waynesburg School
(Amish)
C/o Steven Wengerd 400 Lincoln Lane
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 483-9911
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 483-9911
Grades: 1-9
| 29 students
White Hall School
(Amish)
1419 W Back Mountain Rd
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 935-2506
Belleville, PA 17004
(717) 935-2506
Grades: 1-9
| 24 students
Mifflin County Private Schools (Closed)
School
Location
Grades
Students
941 W Back Mountain Rd
Belleville, PA 17004
Belleville, PA 17004
Grades: 1-9
| 31 students
686 Front Mountain Rd
Allensville, PA 17002
Allensville, PA 17002
Grades: 1-8
| 26 students
5735 E Back Mountain Rd
Belleville, PA 17004
Belleville, PA 17004
Grades: 1-8
| 20 students
2698 Front Mountain Rd
Belleville, PA 17004
Belleville, PA 17004
Grades: 1-9
| 30 students
4568 Front Mountain Rd
Belleville, PA 17004
Belleville, PA 17004
Grades: 1-9
| 28 students
12680 Scenic View Dr
Mill Creek, PA 17060
Mill Creek, PA 17060
Grades: 1-8
| 25 students
C/o Steven Wengerd 400 Linden Lane
Belleville, PA 17004
Belleville, PA 17004
Grades: 1-8
| 29 students
517 Treaster Valley Rd
Milroy, PA 17063
Milroy, PA 17063
Grades: 1-8
| 30 students
5972 E Back Mountain Rd
Reedsville, PA 17084
Reedsville, PA 17084
Grades: 1-8
| 26 students
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top ranked private schools in Mifflin County, PA?
The top ranked private schools in Mifflin County, PA include Belleville Mennonite School, Coffee Run School, and Sacred Heart Of Jesus School.
How many private schools are located in Mifflin County?
24 private schools are located in Mifflin County.
How diverse are private schools in Mifflin County?
Mifflin County private schools are approximately 4% minority students, which is lower than the Pennsylvania private school average of 27%.
What percentage of students in Mifflin County go to private school?
20% of all K-12 students in Mifflin County are educated in private schools (compared to the PA state average of 14%).
What percentage of private schools are religiously affiliated in Mifflin County?
Which private schools in Mifflin County are often viewed compared to one another?
Popular comparisons of private schools in Mifflin County include: Belleville Mennonite School vs. Mifflin County Christian Academy, Sacred Heart Of Jesus School vs. Mifflin County Christian Academy, Mifflin County Christian Academy vs. Belleville Mennonite School
Recent Articles
Podcasts That Will Change the Way You Think About Education
This article highlights a curated selection of podcasts that offer thought-provoking discussions, expert insights, and innovative ideas on various aspects of education. From exploring new teaching methods and technologies to discussing policy changes and social issues, these podcasts provide a wealth of knowledge and inspiration for anyone interested in education. Each podcast is briefly described, highlighting its unique focus and tone.
For-profit vs. Not-for-profit Schools
This comprehensive guide explores the differences between for-profit and not-for-profit private schools, discussing their organizational structures, advantages, and key considerations for parents. It emphasizes that a school's success is determined by its educational quality and management rather than its profit status.
2023-24 Best SSAT Prep Courses Reviewed
This article reviews the top SSAT prep courses, including Test Innovators, Enrollment Management Association (EMA), Princeton Review, Ivy Global, and Kaplan. Each course is evaluated based on its price, in-person and online services, officially licensed materials, instant normative scoring, and free trial options. We'll dive into the features and benefits of each course, helping you understand which one best fits your student's needs and learning style.
