Peachtown Elementary School Photo

Best Cayuga County Private Schools (2026)

For the 2026 school year, there are 10 private schools serving 418 students in Cayuga County, NY (there are 22 public schools, serving 8,691 public students). 5% of all K-12 students in Cayuga County, NY are educated in private schools (compared to the NY state average of 15%).
The top-ranked private schools in Cayuga County, NY include Hillside Childrens Center - Finger Lakes Campus and Creative Minds Montessori School.
The average acceptance rate is 97%, which is higher than the New York private school average acceptance rate of 74%.
60% of private schools in Cayuga County, NY are religiously affiliated (most commonly Mennonite and Catholic).

Top-Ranked Cayuga County Private Schools (2026)

School
Location
Quick Facts
Creative Minds Montessori School
Creative Minds Montessori School Photo - "When children come into contact with nature, they reveal their strength." Dr. Maria Montessori
Montessori School
169 Genesee St
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 406-9495
Gr: PK-5 | 13 students Tuition listed
Hillside Childrens Center - Finger Lakes Campus
Alternative School
7432 County House Rd
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 258-2150
Gr: 4-12 | 38 students
Cayuga Mennonite School
(Mennonite)
7329 Baldwin Rd
Cayuga, NY 13034
(315) 871-8824
Gr: 1-8 | 27 students
Conquest Mennonite School
(Mennonite)
973 Fuller Rd
Port Byron, NY 13140
(315) 776-4236
Gr: 1-8 | 54 students
Frontenac Elementary School
(Seventh Day Adventist)
963 Spring St Rd
Union Springs, NY 13160
(315) 889-5094
Gr: K-8 | 19 students Tuition listed
John Paul II Academy Of Auburn
(Catholic)
Po Box 1318
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 252-4393
Gr: PK-8 | 12 students
Montessori School Of The Finger Lakes
Montessori School
6734 Pine Ridge Road
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 252-2225
Gr: PK-5 | 42 students Tuition listed
Peachtown Elementary School
Peachtown Elementary School Photo
Alternative School
22 Deans Rd
Aurora, NY 13026
(315) 364-8721
Gr: K-8 | 31 students Tuition listed
Tyburn Academy Of Mary Immaculate
(Catholic)
(1)
17 Clymer St
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 252-2937
Gr: 7-12 | 57 students Avg. class size: 15 students Tuition & acceptance rate listed
Union Springs Academy
(Seventh Day Adventist)
40 Spring St
Union Springs, NY 13160
(315) 889-7314
Gr: K-12 | 125 students Avg. class size: 20 students Sports: 3 | Extracurrculars: 4 Tuition & acceptance rate listed
[+] Show Closed Private Schools in Cayuga County, New York

Cayuga County Private Schools (Closed)

School
Location
Quick Facts
89 E Genesee St
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 253-8327
Gr: PK-8 | 139 students
134 Washington St
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 252-5567
Gr: K-9 | 98 students
13817 State Route 90
Locke, NY 13092
Gr: 1-8 | 18 students

Overview

This County (Cayuga County)
This State (NY)
# Schools
10 Schools

Student Body:

# Students
418 Students
430,297 Students
% Average Students of Color
47%
40%

Academics and Faculty:

# Teachers
54 Teachers
41,984 Teachers
Average Student-Teacher Ratio
8:1
10:1
% Average Faculty w/Advanced Degree
75%
76%
Average Class Size
18 students
15 students
Average Number of AP Courses
15 courses
11 courses

Tuition and Acceptance Rate:

Average Yearly Tuition Cost
$11,952
$22,300
Average Summer Program Cost
$125
$2,213
Average Acceptance Rate
97%
74%
Average Endowment Size
$50 million
$48.86 million

Students by Ethnicity:

0.61
0.60
# American Indian Students
1 Student
949 Students
% American Indian Students
n/a
n/a
# Asian Students
23 Students
18,466 Students
% Asian Students
5%
4%
# Hispanic Students
42 Students
33,844 Students
% Hispanic Students
9%
8%
# Black Students
35 Students
33,742 Students
% Black Students
8%
8%
# White Students
263 Students
253,991 Students
% White Students
59%
59%
# Hawaiian Students
2 Students
2,694 Students
% Hawaiian Students
1%
1%
# Two or more races Students
n/a
n/a
% of Two or more races Students
n/a
n/a
# Others Students
80 Students
84,128 Students
% of Others Students
18%
20%
All Ethnic Groups

Extracurriculars and Sports:

Average Number of Extracurriculars
4 extracurriculars
13 extracurriculars
Average Number of Sports
3 sports
7 sports

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top-ranked private schools in Cayuga County, NY?
The top-ranked private schools in Cayuga County, NY include Hillside Childrens Center - Finger Lakes Campus and Creative Minds Montessori School.
How many private schools are located in Cayuga County?
10 private schools are located in Cayuga County.
How diverse are private schools in Cayuga County?
Cayuga County private schools are approximately 47% minority students, which is higher than the New York private school average of 40%.
What percentage of students in Cayuga County go to private school?
5% of all K-12 students in Cayuga County are educated in private schools (compared to the NY state average of 15%).
What percentage of private schools are religiously affiliated in Cayuga County?
60% of private schools in Cayuga County are religiously affiliated (most commonly Mennonite and Catholic).

Recent Articles

Free Private Schools & Voucher Programs in 2025
Free Private Schools & Voucher Programs in 2025
Updated guide to free private schools and school voucher programs, 2025 policies, costs, equity issues, and how families access tuition support.
Social Emotional Learning 2025: Policy, Practice and Outcomes
Social Emotional Learning 2025: Policy, Practice and Outcomes
Updated 2025 review of social emotional learning in schools, research outcomes, key trends, challenges and future paths for parents and educators.
Private School Admissions for Siblings: Costs and Timing
Private School Admissions for Siblings: Costs and Timing
Learn how private school admissions for siblings affect costs, discounts, and timing strategies for families planning multiple enrollments.