Private School Review - Established 2003
Peachtown Elementary School
Creative Minds Montessori School Top 14 ยท Largest Endowment (NY)

Best Cayuga County Private Schools (2026-27)

For the 2026-27 school year, there are 10 private schools serving 418 students in Cayuga County, NY (there are 22 public schools, serving 8,691 public students). 5% of all K-12 students are educated in private schools (compared to the NY state average of 15%).
The average acceptance rate is 97%, which is higher than the New York private school average acceptance rate of 76%.
60% of private schools in Cayuga County, NY are religiously affiliated (most commonly Mennonite and Seventh Day Adventist).

Quick Facts (2026-27)

Quick Facts (2026-27)

Top Ranked Cayuga County Private Schools (2026-27)

Map of Hillside Childrens Center - Finger Lakes Campus
Hillside Childrens Center - Finger Lakes Campus
Gr: 4-12 | 38 students
Alternative School
7432 County House Rd
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 258-2150
View Profile
Map of Cayuga Mennonite School
Cayuga Mennonite School
Gr: 1-8 | 27 students
Mennonite
7329 Baldwin Rd
Cayuga, NY 13034
(315) 871-8824
View Profile
Map of Conquest Mennonite School
Conquest Mennonite School
Gr: 1-8 | 54 students
Mennonite
973 Fuller Rd
Port Byron, NY 13140
(315) 776-4236
View Profile
Creative Minds Montessori School Photo
Creative Minds Montessori School
Gr: PK-5 | 13 students
Montessori School
169 Genesee St
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 406-9495
View Profile
Map of Frontenac Elementary School
Frontenac Elementary School
Gr: K-8 | 19 students
Seventh Day Adventist
963 Spring St Rd
Union Springs, NY 13160
(315) 889-5094
View Profile
Map of John Paul II Academy Of Auburn
John Paul II Academy Of Auburn
Gr: PK-8 | 12 students
Catholic
Po Box 1318
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 252-4393
View Profile
Map of Montessori School Of The Finger Lakes
Montessori School Of The Finger Lakes
Gr: PK-5 | 42 students
Montessori School
6734 Pine Ridge Road
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 252-2225
View Profile
Peachtown Elementary School Photo
Peachtown Elementary School
Gr: K-8 | 31 students
Alternative School
22 Deans Rd
Aurora, NY 13026
(315) 364-8721
View Profile
Map of Tyburn Academy Of Mary Immaculate
Tyburn Academy Of Mary Immaculate
Gr: 7-12 | 57 students
Avg. class size: 15 students
Catholic
17 Clymer St
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 252-2937
(1)
View Profile
Map of Union Springs Academy
Union Springs Academy
Gr: K-12 | 125 students
Avg. class size: 20 students
Sports: 3 | Extracurriculars: 4
Seventh Day Adventist
40 Spring St
Union Springs, NY 13160
(315) 889-7314
View Profile
[+] Show Closed Private Schools in Cayuga County, New York

Cayuga County Private Schools (Closed)

Map of St. Joseph School
St. Joseph School
Gr: PK-8 | 139 students
Catholic
89 E Genesee St
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 253-8327
View Profile
Map of Ss Peter & Paul Ukrainian Catholic School
Ss Peter & Paul Ukrainian Catholic School
Gr: K-9 | 98 students
Catholic
134 Washington St
Auburn, NY 13021
(315) 252-5567
View Profile
Map of Sunny Meadows Parochial School
Sunny Meadows Parochial School
Gr: 1-8 | 18 students
Amish
13817 State Route 90
Locke, NY 13092
View Profile

Overview

Category
This State (NY)
US
# Schools
10 Schools

Trends in Total Number of Private Schools

YearCayuga County Total Schools
202510
202412
202312
20229
202110
202010
201910
201810
20179
20169
201511
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

# Students
418 Students
424,623 Students

Trends in the Average Number of Students Per Private School

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
202542246179
202444238172
202345238174
202245250185
202158245180
202058242171
201962247175
201861245172
201764242180
201664241178
201563230167
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

% Average Students of Color
47%
39%

Percentage of Students of Color Trends (2015-2025)

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
202547%40%34%
202428%40%34%
202318%40%33%
202223%40%33%
202116%41%32%
202016%41%32%
201914%40%31%
201814%39%31%
201718%40%32%
201618%40%32%
201515%41%32%
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

Academics and Faculty:

# Teachers
54 Teachers
41,519 Teachers
Average Student-Teacher Ratio
8:1
10:1

Student-Teacher Ratio Trends (2015-2025)

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
20258:110:111:1
20249:110:111:1
20238:111:111:1
20227:111:111:1
20218:111:111:1
20208:111:112:1
20198:111:112:1
20188:111:112:1
20179:111:112:1
20169:111:112:1
20159:112:112:1
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

% Average Faculty w/Advanced Degree
75%
76%

Percentage of Faculty With Advanced Degrees Trends (2021-2025)

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
202575%76%55%
202475%75%54%
202375%75%54%
202275%76%54%
202175%74%54%
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

Average Class Size
18 students
15 students
Average Number of AP Courses
15 courses
11 courses

Tuition and Acceptance Rate:

Average Yearly Tuition Cost
$11,952
$22,451

Tuition Cost Trends (2015-2025)

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
2025$11,952$22,300$15,012
2024$5,133$21,636$13,254
2023$5,133$21,117$12,626
2022$5,133$19,707$12,187
2021$5,133$19,162$11,800
2020$5,133$18,832$11,512
2019$5,133$18,073$11,293
2018$4,400$17,784$11,017
2017$4,400$16,583$10,708
2016$6,400$14,881$10,356
2015$6,400$14,120$9,939
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

Average Summer Program Cost
$125
$2,359

Summer Program Cost Trends (2021-2025)

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
2025$125$2,213$1,152
2024$125$2,240$1,128
2023$125$2,493$1,156
2022$125$2,022$1,102
2021$125$2,090$1,125
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

Average Acceptance Rate
97%
76%
Average Endowment Size
$50 million
$48.86 million

Students by Ethnicity:

0.61
0.59

Diversity Score Trends

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
20250.610.600.65
20240.570.600.65
20230.490.620.65
20220.380.620.64
20210.410.620.64
20200.410.620.64
20190.470.610.63
20180.460.610.63
20170.480.610.61
20160.480.620.61
20150.430.620.61
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

# American Indian Students
1 Student
949 Students
% American Indian Students
n/a
n/a
# Asian Students
23 Students
18,397 Students
% Asian Students
5%
5%

Asian Student Percentage Trends

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
20256%4%5%
20244%4%5%
20233%4%5%
20224%5%4%
20213%5%4%
20203%4%4%
20193%5%4%
20183%5%4%
20174%4%4%
20164%4%4%
20153%4%4%
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

# Hispanic Students
42 Students
33,759 Students
% Hispanic Students
9%
8%

Hispanic Student Percentage Trends

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
20259%8%9%
20248%8%9%
20234%9%9%
20224%9%8%
20214%9%9%
20204%9%9%
20193%10%8%
20183%10%8%
20174%9%8%
20164%9%8%
20153%9%8%
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

# Black Students
35 Students
33,696 Students
% Black Students
8%
8%

Black Student Percentage Trends

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
20258%8%7%
20247%8%7%
20234%9%8%
20226%9%7%
20214%9%7%
20204%9%8%
20195%9%7%
20185%9%7%
20174%11%7%
20164%11%7%
20154%11%8%
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

# White Students
263 Students
252,994 Students
% White Students
59%
60%

White Student Percentage Trends

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
202559%59%52%
202462%59%52%
202369%57%52%
202279%57%54%
202176%57%54%
202076%58%54%
201971%58%56%
201871%58%56%
201770%58%58%
201670%58%58%
201574%58%58%
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

# Hawaiian Students
2 Students
538 Students
% Hawaiian Students
1%
n/a
# Two or more races Students
n/a
n/a
% of Two or more races Students
n/a
n/a
# Others Students
80 Students
81,443 Students
% of Others Students
18%
19%

Other Races Student Percentage Trends

YearCayuga County AverageNew York (NY) AverageNational Average
202518%20%26%
202418%20%26%
202319%20%25%
20226%18%25%
202112%19%25%
202012%19%24%
201917%18%24%
201817%18%23%
201717%18%22%
201617%18%22%
201515%18%21%
Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON
Download Full County Data: Full County Dataset XML | Full County Dataset JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

All Ethnic Groups

Extracurriculars and Sports:

Average Number of Extracurriculars
4 extracurriculars
13 extracurriculars
Average Number of Sports
3 sports
7 sports

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top ranked private schools in Cayuga County, NY?
The top ranked private schools in Cayuga County, NY is Hillside Childrens Center - Finger Lakes Campus.
How many private schools are located in Cayuga County?
10 private schools are located in Cayuga County.
How diverse are private schools in Cayuga County?
Cayuga County private schools are approximately 47% minority students, which is higher than the New York private school average of 39%.
What percentage of students in Cayuga County go to private school?
5% of all K-12 students in Cayuga County are educated in private schools (compared to the NY state average of 15%).
What percentage of private schools are religiously affiliated in Cayuga County?
60% of private schools in Cayuga County are religiously affiliated (most commonly Mennonite and Seventh Day Adventist).

Recent Articles

How Much Homework Is Too Much?
How Much Homework Is Too Much?
Learn how to compare private school homework expectations, recognize excessive workloads, evaluate assignment quality, and ask better questions about academic balance before choosing a school for your child.
Learning Support Without a Formal Program
Learning Support Without a Formal Program
Learn what private schools mean by informal learning support, how services differ from formal programs, and which questions families should ask before choosing the right school today.
Beyond AP vs. IB: How to Judge Academic Rigor
Beyond AP vs. IB: How to Judge Academic Rigor
Learn how to judge academic rigor at private schools without AP or IB by examining curriculum depth, assessments, faculty expectations, advanced coursework, student work, and college preparation outcomes.

Filter Schools

School Level
Must Offer Grade
▼ Show more
Gender
School Focus
Religious Affiliation
ADD/ADHD Support
Summer Program

Quick Links

SCHOOL SEARCH TOOLS:
SCHOOL BY TYPE (NY):
OPEN-HOUSES & JOBS:
PUBLIC & BOARDING SCHOOLS:
PRIVATE SCHOOL DATA:

Most Popular Articles

Private School Governance Structures Explained
Private School Governance Structures Explained
 Is Paying More Worth It? Mid-Tuition vs. Premium Private Schools
Is Paying More Worth It? Mid-Tuition vs. Premium Private Schools
New York Private Schools By Tuition Cost
New York Private Schools By Tuition Cost

More Articles

Leadership in Private Education
Programs for Exceptional Learners
Well-Rounded Achievements
Excellence in School Security
Timeless School Insights