For the 2026 school year, there are 10 private elementary schools serving 2,731 students in 53209, WI.
The top-ranked private elementary schools in 53209, WI include Holy Redeemer Christian Academy, Hope Christian School: Fidelis, and Eastbrook Academy.
The average acceptance rate is 96%, which is higher than the Wisconsin private elementary school average acceptance rate of 90%.
100% of private elementary schools in 53209, WI are religiously affiliated (most commonly Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod and Christian).
Top-Ranked 53209 Wisconsin Private Elementary Schools (2026)
School
Location
Quick Facts
Atonement Lutheran School
(Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
4224 W Ruby Ave
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 871-1224
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 871-1224
Gr: PK-8 | 424 students Avg. class size: 27 students
5375 N Green Bay Avenue
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 228-7905
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 228-7905
Gr: PK-12 | 387 students Avg. class size: 16 students Sports: 6 | Extracurrculars: 3 Tuition & acceptance rate listed
Garden Homes Lutheran School ![Garden Homes Lutheran School Photo - Our student council--The G-House of Representatives--works with students, staff, and school administration to make the school better.]( "Garden Homes Lutheran School Photo - Our student council--The G-House of Representatives--works with students, staff, and school administration to make the school better.")
(Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
2450 W Roosevelt Drive
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 444-9050
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 444-9050
Gr: PK-8 | 280 students Avg. class size: 23 students Sports: 4 | Extracurrculars: 6 Tuition & acceptance rate listed
Holy Redeemer Christian Academy
(Church of God in Christ)
3500 W Mother Daniels Way
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 466-1800
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 466-1800
Gr: PK-12 | 400 students
Hope Christian School: Fidelis
(Christian)
4200 W Douglas Ave
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 203-5270
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 203-5270
Gr: PK-8 | 493 students Tuition listed
4065 N 25th St
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 444-1146
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 444-1146
Gr: K-12 | 168 students Acceptance rate listed
5268 N. 35th Street
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 466-3284
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 466-3284
Gr: K-10 | 206 students
Light House Youth Center
Alternative School (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
2475 W Roosevelt Dr
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 469-0750
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 469-0750
Gr: 4-12 | 137 students
Northwest Catholic School
(Catholic)
7140 N 41st St
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 352-6927
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 352-6927
Gr: PK-8 | 164 students
Risen Savior Lutheran School - East Campus
(Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
3909 W Clinton Ave
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 446-5631
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 446-5631
Gr: K-6 | 72 students Avg. class size: 15 students Sports: 5 Tuition & acceptance rate listed
53209, Wisconsin Private Schools (Closed)
School
Location
Quick Facts
The Wisconsin Center for Gifted Learners (Closed 2022)
Special Program Emphasis
2315 W Good Hope Road Rd, Room 23
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 351-4441
Milwaukee, WI 53209
(414) 351-4441
Gr: PK-8
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-ranked private elementary schools in 53209, WI?
The top-ranked private elementary schools in 53209, WI include Holy Redeemer Christian Academy, Hope Christian School: Fidelis, and Eastbrook Academy.
How many private elementary schools are located in 53209?
10 private elementary schools are located in 53209.
How diverse are private elementary schools in 53209?
53209 private elementary schools are approximately 96% minority students, which is higher than the Wisconsin private school average of 34%.
What percentage of private elementary schools are religiously affiliated in 53209?
100% of private elementary schools in 53209 are religiously affiliated (most commonly Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod and Christian).
Recent Articles
How to Ask About Staff Screening Without Apologizing
Parents should feel comfortable asking how private schools screen employees. Learn which questions matter, what answers to expect, and why transparency about hiring and student safety is a hallmark of a well-managed school.
What Facility Safety Tells You About School Oversight
A school's facilities reveal far more than appearance. Learn how building maintenance, emergency preparedness, and campus safety practices can help parents evaluate school leadership, oversight, and long-term commitment to student well-being.
Is the School Legally a School? A Parent Verification Checklist
Before enrolling your child in a private school, learn how to verify that it is legally operating, properly accredited, and authorized to issue recognized diplomas with this practical parent checklist for making a confident school choice.
