Brookfield Academy Top 3 · Highest Avg. SAT Score (WI)

The Prairie School Top 9 · Highest Avg. ACT Score (WI)

Hickory Hill Academy Top 7 · Highest % Faculty w/ Adv. Degrees (WI)

Home > Wisconsin > Most Selective Schools

Most Selective Private Elementary Schools in Wisconsin

The average private elementary school acceptance rate in Wisconsin is 90% per year (2026).

The most selective school in Wisconsin is St. John The Baptist Catholic School, Randolph Christian School, and Milwaukee Seventh-day Adventist School, among others each with an acceptance rate of 25%.

Quick Facts (2026)

# WI Schools Ranked: 154
Top 20 Range (Acceptance Rate): 25%–80%
WI School Avg.: 90%
National School Avg.: 83%

Quick Facts (2026)

# WI Schools Ranked: 154
Top 20 Range (Acceptance Rate): 25%–80%
WI School Avg.: 90%
National School Avg.: 83%

Wisconsin Average Acceptance Rate (Trends)

View Data

Year	Wisconsin (WI) avg
2025	89%
2024	94%
2023	95%
2022	95%
2021	96%
2020	96%
2019	95%
2018	95%
2017	95%
2016	95%
2015	95%

Download Table: Download as CSV | Download as XML | Download as JSON

Note: Data may not be displayed on any public-facing website or service that replicates or resembles a school search or review portal without prior written permission. See our Terms of Service.

Show school map — Wisconsin (acceptance rate range: 25%–80%, avg 90%)

Acceptance Rate Range: 25% 90% Avg. Acceptance Rate: 67%

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Wisconsin average private elementary schools acceptance rate?

The Wisconsin average private elementary schools acceptance rate is 90% for 2026.

What are the most selective private elementary schools in Wisconsin?

The top ranked private elementary schools in Wisconsin include Messiah Lutheran School, Milwaukee Seventh-day Adventist School and Randolph Christian School.

Recent Articles

August 25, 2026

Will This Curriculum Still Matter in 2035?

Learn how to evaluate future-ready private school curricula for 2035, focusing on durable knowledge, critical thinking, AI literacy, adaptability, communication, creativity, and real-world learning before choosing a school.

August 25, 2026

Private Schools for Creators, Trades & Startups

Explore how private schools support non-traditional career paths in creative industries, skilled trades, and entrepreneurship, plus what families should evaluate when choosing specialized programs for future-ready students today.

August 25, 2026

First 90 Days at Private School: Parent Guide

Learn how to read your child’s first 90 days at private school, distinguish healthy adjustment from genuine struggles, and know when academic, social, or emotional concerns require action.