Most Selective Private Schools in Wisconsin

All Schools
(102)
All Schools
(102)
 
High Schools
(27)
High Schools
(27)
 
Elementary Schools
(87)
Elementary Schools
(87)
 
Preschools
(83)
Preschools
(83)
 
  • The average private school acceptance rate in Wisconsin is approximately 94% per year (2019-20).
  • The most selective private schools are listed below (where sufficient data available).
  • The most selective school in Wisconsin is currently Our Savior Lutheran School, with an acceptance rate of 1%.

Most Selective Private Schools in Wisconsin (2019-20)

  • School Acceptance Rate Grades Location
  • Rank: #11.
    Our Savior Lutheran School
    (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 1%
    Grades: PK-81332 Arrowhead Rd
    Grafton, WI 53024
    (262)377-7780

  • Rank: #22.
    Wayland Academy
    Wayland Academy Photo
    Special Program Emphasis
    Acceptance Rate: 22%
    Grades: 9-12101 N University Avenue
    Beaver Dam, WI 53916
    (920)885-3373

  • Rank: #33.
    Conserve School
    Conserve School Photo - Conserve School opening ceremony.
    Special Program Emphasis
    Acceptance Rate: 33%
    Grades: 10-115400 N Black Oak Lake Road
    Land O Lakes, WI 54540
    (715)547-1300

  • Rank: #44.
    St Thomas More High School
    St Thomas More High School Photo
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 73%
    Grades: 9-122601 E Morgan Ave
    Milwaukee, WI 53207
    (414)481-8370

  • Rank: #55.
    St John's Lutheran School
    (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 75%
    Grades: PK-8515 5th St
    Baraboo, WI 53913
    (608)355-3860

  • Rank: #6-76.-7.
    Walbridge School
    Alternative School
    Acceptance Rate: 80%
    Grades: 2-127035 Old Sauk Road
    Madison, WI 53717
    (608)833-1338

  • Rank: #6-76.-7.
    Wolf River Lutheran High School
    Wolf River Lutheran High School Photo
    (Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 80%
    Grades: 9-12W7467 River Bend Rd
    Shawano, WI 54166
    (715)745-2400

  • Rank: #8-98.-9.
    Badger State Baptist School
    (Baptist)
    Acceptance Rate: 85%
    Grades: PK-128519 South 13th Street
    Oak Creek, WI 53154
    (414)301-9319

  • Rank: #8-98.-9.
    St Paul Lutheran School
    (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 85%
    Grades: PK-81319 Larson St
    Bloomer, WI 54724
    (715)568-4322

  • Rank: #1010.
    St Lawrence Seminary High School
    St Lawrence Seminary High School Photo
    All-boys (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 89%
    Grades: 9-12301 Church Street
    Mount Calvary, WI 53057
    (920)753-7500

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Bethany Lutheran
    (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: K-82100 75th St
    Kenosha, WI 53143
    (262)654-3234

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Faith Christian School
    Faith Christian School Photo - Blessed with a wonderful family-focused community and beautiful facility, Faith Christian School is worth your time to schedule a visit.
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-12W5525 State Hwy 67
    Williams Bay, WI 53191
    (262)245-9404

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Grace Lutheran School
    Grace Lutheran School Photo
    (Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-88537 S Pennsylvania Ave
    Oak Creek, WI 53154
    (414)762-3655

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Loving Shepherd Lutheran School
    (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-83909 W Clinton Ave
    Milwaukee, WI 53209
    (414)352-2662

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Martin Luther Lutheran School
    (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-6807 Adams Street
    Neenah, WI 54956
    (920)725-8047

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Montessori Childrens House
    Montessori Childrens House Photo - Children chose individual work in Practical Life area. These activities help build concentration, attention to detail and helps develop small muscle control which are all preparation for math, reading and writing.
    Montessori School
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: NS-K920 61st Street
    Kenosha, WI 53143
    (262)658-1797

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Mt. Lebanon Evangelical Lutheran School
    (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-86100 W Hampton Avenue
    Milwaukee, WI 53218
    (414)464-5410

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Nature's Classroom Montessori
    Nature's Classroom Montessori Photo - Nature's Classroom Institute and Montessori School students building a new boardwalk.
    Montessori School
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: NS-12W336 S8455 Hwy E
    Mukwonago, WI 53149
    (262)363-2815

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Prairie Hill Waldorf School
    Prairie Hill Waldorf School Photo - Students at Prairie Hill Waldorf School create their own textbooks, called "main lesson books," from lessons and material presented by teachers and from their own creativity and inspiration.
    Special Program Emphasis
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-8N14w29143 Silvernail Rd
    Pewaukee, WI 53072
    (262)646-7497

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Providence Academy
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: NS-121420 Division Street
    Green Bay, WI 54303
    (920)592-0890

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    St Pauls Lutheran School
    St Pauls Lutheran School Photo - Entrance #1, Main entrance
    (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-8S66 W14325 Janesville Rd
    Muskego, WI 53150
    (414)422-0320

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Valley Christian School
    Valley Christian School Photo
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: K-12933A 248th Street
    Osceola, WI 54020
    (715)294-3373

  • Rank: #11-2311.-23.
    Victory Christian High School
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: 9-12112 Hale Rd
    Neosho, WI 53059
    (920)625-3995

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    Brookfield Academy
    Brookfield Academy Photo - K4 to Graduation Day!
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-123462 N Brookfield Rd
    Brookfield, WI 53045
    (262)783-3200

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    Eastbrook Academy
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: NS-125375 N Green Bay Avenue
    Milwaukee, WI 53209
    (414)228-7905

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    First German Evangelical Lutheran School
    (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-81025 S 8th St
    Manitowoc, WI 54220
    (920)682-7021

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    Green Bay Trinity Lutheran School
    (Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: K-8120 S Henry Street
    Green Bay, WI 54302
    (920)655-4673

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    Immaculate Heart Of Mary School
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-84913 Schofield St
    Madison, WI 53716
    (608)222-8831

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    Immanuel Lutheran School
    (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-8916 Pine St
    Manitowoc, WI 54220
    (920)684-3404

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    Mother Of Good Counsel
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-83001 N 68th St
    Milwaukee, WI 53210
    (414)442-7600

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    Our Lady Queen Of Peace School
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-82733 W Euclid Avenue
    Milwaukee, WI 53215
    (414)672-6660

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    Our Redeemer Lutheran School
    (Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-810025 West North Avenue
    Milwaukee, WI 53226
    (414)258-4558

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    St. Bruno Parish School
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-8246 W Ottawa Avenue
    Dousman, WI 53118
    (262)965-2291

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    St. Joseph School
    St. Joseph School Photo - Welcome to St. Joseph School
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-8991 Pilgrim Way
    Green Bay, WI 54304
    (920)499-9969

  • Rank: #24-3924.-39.
    St Mary Catholic School
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-228 Naber St
    Mayville, WI 53050
    (920)387-2920

Recent Articles
SSAT and ISEE scores are one part of the total picture which most private school admissions staff review. These standardized tests reveal what you have learned in key mastery areas.
Do you think your son has a learning disability? Not sure what to do? A special needs school might be the way to go.
You thought everything was set. The test scores were excellent. She had glowing teacher recommendations. The visit and the interview went well. But the school didn't accept your child. What do you do now?