For the 2026 school year, there are 2 private elementary schools serving 501 students in East Islip, NY.
The top-ranked private elementary schools in East Islip, NY include St. Mary School and Harrow International School New York.
The average acceptance rate is 53%, which is lower than the New York private elementary school average acceptance rate of 76%.
50% of private elementary schools in East Islip, NY are religiously affiliated (most commonly Catholic).
Top-Ranked East Islip Private Elementary Schools (2026)
School
Location
Quick Facts
500 Montauk Highway
East Islip, NY 11769
(631) 869-1572
East Islip, NY 11769
(631) 869-1572
Gr: 6-12 Avg. class size: 8 students Sports: 11 Tuition & acceptance rate listed
St. Mary School
(Catholic)
16 Harrison Ave
East Islip, NY 11730
(631) 581-3423
East Islip, NY 11730
(631) 581-3423
Gr: PK-8 | 501 students Tuition & acceptance rate listed
East Islip, New York Private Schools (Closed)
School
Location
Quick Facts
Chatterbox Day School (Closed 2015)
Daycare / Preschool
52 Hawthorne Ave
East Islip, NY 11730
(631) 581-4756
East Islip, NY 11730
(631) 581-4756
Gr: PK-1 | 61 students
74 Suffolk Lane
East Islip, NY 11730
(631) 581-1035
East Islip, NY 11730
(631) 581-1035
Gr: PK-12 | 63 students
Overview
This Town (East Islip)
This State (NY)
# Schools
2 Schools
Student Body:
# Students
501 Students
342,443 Students
% Average Students of Color
32%
37%
Academics and Faculty:
# Teachers
42 Teachers
34,424 Teachers
Average Student-Teacher Ratio
19:1
10:1
% Average Faculty w/Advanced Degree
90%
76%
Average Class Size
8 students
15 students
Tuition and Acceptance Rate:
Average Yearly Tuition Cost
$43,350
$22,319
Average Acceptance Rate
53%
76%
Students by Ethnicity:
Diversity Score
0.67
0.57
# American Indian Students
1 Student
810 Students
% American Indian Students
n/a
n/a
# Asian Students
3 Students
14,470 Students
% Asian Students
1%
4%
# Hispanic Students
64 Students
23,952 Students
% Hispanic Students
13%
7%
# Black Students
36 Students
26,065 Students
% Black Students
7%
8%
# White Students
226 Students
214,023 Students
% White Students
45%
63%
# Hawaiian Students
1 Student
420 Students
% Hawaiian Students
n/a
n/a
# Two or more races Students
n/a
n/a
% of Two or more races Students
n/a
n/a
# Others Students
170 Students
63,021 Students
% of Others Students
34%
18%
All Ethnic Groups
Extracurriculars and Sports:
Average Number of Sports
11 sports
7 sports
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-ranked private elementary schools in East Islip, NY?
The top-ranked private elementary schools in East Islip, NY include St. Mary School and Harrow International School New York.
How many private elementary schools are located in East Islip?
2 private elementary schools are located in East Islip.
What percentage of private elementary schools are religiously affiliated in East Islip?
50% of private elementary schools in East Islip are religiously affiliated (most commonly Catholic).
Recent Articles
Private School Closures and Consolidations: Warning Signs to Watch
Learn the financial, enrollment, and leadership warning signs that may indicate a private school is at risk of closure or consolidation, and how families can prepare.
AI Tutoring in Private Schools: Innovation or Risk?
Discover how AI tutoring is changing private education, the benefits and risks for students, and what parents should ask before enrolling.
What New Cell Phone Laws Mean for Private School Families
Learn how new cell phone laws are affecting private schools, what parents should expect, and how to evaluate school technology policies in 2026.