Home > Find Schools > Top Lists > New York > Most Selective Schools

Most Selective Private Elementary Schools in New York

The average private elementary school acceptance rate in New York is 74% per year (2025).

The most selective school in New York is Castle Island Bilingual Montessori, with an acceptance rate of 5%.

Harrow International School New York Photo - Combining 450 years of outstanding pedagogy at Harrow School, one of the UK's most prestigious independent schools, with the vibrancy of New York and a stunning waterfront campus spread over more than 170 acres, Harrow New York offers a premium day and boarding school education for girls and boys in Grades 6-12.

Green Meadow Waldorf School Photo - Green Meadow`s middle school academic curriculum engages the budding capacities and immense curiosity of the young teenager. Through practical interdisciplinary experiences, age appropriate challenges, and meaningful social interactions, students thrive academically and emotionally. Every day, students take part in immersive, explorative inquiry, broadening and deepening their understanding of the world.

Adelphi Academy of Brooklyn Photo - Adelphi Academy of Brooklyn's historic Bay Ridge campus is located at 8515 Ridge Boulevard, in the heart of Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. .

The Knox School Photo - Founded in 1904, The Knox School is Long Island`s oldest established private school. Our inclusive environment serves grades 6-12 and Post-Graduate, providing students with a broad world perspective and a wide range of skills to prepare them for the next phase of their journeys.

Birch Wathen Lenox School Photo - The Birch Wathen Lenox School

Saint Therese Classical Academy and Chesterton Academy Photo - This years dinner theater production of the original "Crazy Times at the Gut Bucket Cafe."

A Fantis School Photo - 8th Graders visit Greece as part of a multi-year cultural exchange program.

Westbury Friends School Photo - Apples picked from our apple tree. Now on to making apple pie.

The Laurel Hill School Photo - One visit can change your child's future.

The IDEAL School of Manhattan Photo - Students show the kindness snowflakes that they made.

Immaculate Conception School Photo - Immaculate Conception School is a Catholic elementary school that provides a strong faith-based foundation and a focus on academic excellence for students from PreK-3 through 8th grade. ICS is committed to the spiritual and personal development of the whole child through education, prayer, and service.

Vincent Smith School Photo - Upper School entrance

Rodeph Sholom School Photo - Rodeph Sholom School has three distinct divisions: Early Childhood, Elementary, and Middle School, allowing dedicated focus on each developmental phase.

The Chapel School Photo - The Chapel School's small class sizes ... max 14 in preschool, 18 in K-5 and 16 in middle school ... provide opportunities for personal, individualized instruction and a strong sense of community!

George Jackson Academy Photo - At George Jackson Academy, smart is cool, learning is fun, and boys embrace their uniqueness within a brotherhood that supports them every step of the way of middle school and beyond.

Acceptance Rate Range: 5% 25% Avg. Acceptance Rate: 22%

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the New York average private elementary schools acceptance rate?

The New York average private elementary schools acceptance rate is 74% for 2025.

What are the most selective private elementary schools in New York?

The top ranked private elementary schools in New York include Castle Island Bilingual Montessori, R T Hudson Elementary School and United Nations International School.

Recent Articles

June 09, 2025

Is It Easier to Land a Private School Job When You're Already Employed?

Is it easier to land a private school job when you're already employed? This article breaks down employer biases, networking advantages, and negotiation leverage—plus the latest hiring trends in independent schools. If you’re considering a move, here’s how to maximize your position.

June 09, 2025

How to Secure a Private School Job When You're Unemployed Without the Stigma

Finding a private school job while unemployed can be tough, but it doesn't have to hold you back. This article breaks down networking strategies, ways to stand out, and smart approaches to keep your confidence strong. Learn how to turn setbacks into strengths and secure the right opportunity—without the stigma.

June 09, 2025

The Private School Job Hunt: Insider Tips for Employed & Unemployed Educators

Navigating the private school job market? Whether you're employed or unemployed, the right strategy can make all the difference. This article breaks down essential steps to keep your resume sharp, expand your network, and stay visible in the education community. Learn insider tips to position yourself for success in private schools.