For the 2026 school year, there are 4 private elementary schools serving 428 students in North Tonawanda, NY.
The top-ranked private elementary schools in North Tonawanda, NY include St. Matthew Lutheran School and St. John Lutheran School.
The average acceptance rate is 99%, which is higher than the New York private elementary school average acceptance rate of 76%.
100% of private elementary schools in North Tonawanda, NY are religiously affiliated (most commonly Lutheran Church Missouri Synod and Catholic).
Top-Ranked North Tonawanda Private Elementary Schools (2026)
School
Location
Quick Facts
6950 Ward Road
North Tonawanda, NY 14120
(716) 693-9677
North Tonawanda, NY 14120
(716) 693-9677
Gr: PK-8 | 168 students Avg. class size: 15 students Sports: 5 | Extracurrculars: 8 Tuition & acceptance rate listed
St. Matthew Lutheran School
(Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
875 Eggert Drive
North Tonawanda, NY 14120
(716) 692-1811
North Tonawanda, NY 14120
(716) 692-1811
Gr: NS-6 | 52 students Avg. class size: 13 students Sports: 5 Tuition & acceptance rate listed
789 Gilmore Ave
North Tonawanda, NY 14120
(716) 433-1652
North Tonawanda, NY 14120
(716) 433-1652
Gr: K-12 | 87 students Sports: 10 | Extracurrculars: 2 Tuition listed
North Tonawanda Catholic School
(Catholic)
75 Keil St
North Tonawanda, NY 14120
(716) 693-0442
North Tonawanda, NY 14120
(716) 693-0442
Gr: K-9 | 121 students
North Tonawanda, New York Private Schools (Closed)
School
Location
Quick Facts
First Baptist Christian School (Closed 2004)
Alternative School (Baptist)
530 Meadow Drive
North Tonawanda, NY 14120
(716) 894-8839
North Tonawanda, NY 14120
(716) 894-8839
Gr: 3-12 | 12 students
Overview
This Town (North Tonawanda)
This State (NY)
# Schools
4 Schools
Student Body:
# Students
428 Students
347,002 Students
% Average Students of Color
8%
39%
Academics and Faculty:
# Teachers
47 Teachers
34,753 Teachers
Average Student-Teacher Ratio
9:1
10:1
% Average Faculty w/Advanced Degree
75%
76%
Average Class Size
14 students
15 students
Average Number of AP Courses
2 courses
11 courses
Average SAT score
1090
(Out of 1600)
1268
Tuition and Acceptance Rate:
Average Yearly Tuition Cost
$3,700
$22,363
Average % on Financial Aid
18%
32%
Average Financial Aid Grant
$850
$9,366
Average Acceptance Rate
99%
76%
Students by Ethnicity:
Diversity Score
0.48
0.58
# American Indian Students
n/a
810 Students
% American Indian Students
n/a
n/a
# Asian Students
2 Students
14,476 Students
% Asian Students
1%
4%
# Hispanic Students
21 Students
23,963 Students
% Hispanic Students
4%
7%
# Black Students
9 Students
26,102 Students
% Black Students
2%
7%
# White Students
336 Students
214,256 Students
% White Students
67%
62%
# Hawaiian Students
n/a
2,576 Students
% Hawaiian Students
n/a
1%
# Two or more races Students
n/a
n/a
% of Two or more races Students
n/a
n/a
# Others Students
131 Students
65,229 Students
% of Others Students
26%
19%
All Ethnic Groups
Extracurriculars and Sports:
Average Number of Extracurriculars
5 extracurriculars
12 extracurriculars
Average Number of Sports
7 sports
7 sports
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-ranked private elementary schools in North Tonawanda, NY?
The top-ranked private elementary schools in North Tonawanda, NY include St. Matthew Lutheran School and St. John Lutheran School.
How many private elementary schools are located in North Tonawanda?
4 private elementary schools are located in North Tonawanda.
What percentage of private elementary schools are religiously affiliated in North Tonawanda?
100% of private elementary schools in North Tonawanda are religiously affiliated (most commonly Lutheran Church Missouri Synod and Catholic).
Recent Articles
Financial Aid 101 for Private School Families 2026
Guide to private school financial aid in 2026, with current costs, key planning timelines and practical steps parents need to maximize aid options.
Why Extracurricular Activities Matter in 2026
Discover why extracurricular activities remain essential in 2026, with updated research, costs, and admissions insights for parents and students.
How to Appeal for Financial Aid After Admission
Learn how to appeal for financial aid after admission to a private school, with expert steps, timelines, and 2026 updates for families.