The community of Saint Matthew Catholic School is dedicated to provide a faith-filled Catholic education that fosters the growth of the whole child. Through developmentally appropriate academics, we facilitate social growth in a safe environment and inspire self-discipline, personal responsibility, and a concern for others in the world.
Quick Facts (2025-26)
- Top Ranked IN School
- Grades: Prekindergarten-8
- Enrollment: 380 students
- Yearly Tuition: $5,140
- Acceptance rate: 95%
- Average class size: 25 students
- Application Deadline: None / Rolling
- Source: Verified school update
Top Rankings
St. Matthew Catholic School ranks among the top 20% of private schools in Indiana for:
Category
Attribute
Student Body
Sports offered
Extracurriculars
School Overview
School Membership(s)School Assoc.
Religious Affiliation
Grades Offered
Grades Prekindergarten-8
ADD/ADHD Support
Yes
Learning Difference Programs
Yes
Learning Programs Supported
Language- and mathematics-based support
Year Founded
1958
School Calendar
Last Day of School
Mon. May 25, 2026
Student Body
Total Students
380 students
Student Body Type
Co-ed
% Students of Color
28%
State avg.: 26%
Students by Grade

Academics and Faculty
Total Classroom Teachers
27 teachers
Student-Teacher Ratio
14:1
National avg.: 13:1
% Faculty w/Advanced Degree
20%
Average Class Size
25 students
Advanced Courses
Middle School Advanced Mathematics
Classroom Dress Code
Casual
Khaki pants with logo polo shirt
Tuition and Acceptance Rate
Admission Deadline
None / Rolling
Yearly Tuition Cost
Tuition Notes
Non-parishioner, Catholic - $6455
Non-parishioner, Non-Catholic - $8650
Acceptance Rate
95%
National avg.: 81%
Admissions Director
Robin Sobolewski
Application URL
Sports
Total Sports Offered
10 sports
Extracurriculars
Total ExtracurricularsTotal Extra-curric.
13 extracurriculars
ExtracurricularsExtra-curric.
Elementary Mathematics BowlElementary Spell Bowl
Middle School Science FairMiddle School Speech Team
Middle School Spell BowlMiddle School Spring Play
Club or Organization:
Academic Challenge @ Cathedral HSChess Club
Girl and Boy ScoutsRobotics Team
Arts and Music Programs:
Elementary Band and ChoirMiddle School Band and Choir
Recreational Athletic Programs:
CYO Sports
School Notes
- Families are encouraged to apply for enrollment early for the following year. Wait lists are possible for future years as well. Students transferring from out-of-area schools are considered on a rolling date.
Source: Verified school update
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does St. Matthew Catholic School cost?
St. Matthew Catholic School's tuition is approximately $5,140 for private students.
What is the acceptance rate of St. Matthew Catholic School?
The acceptance rate of St. Matthew Catholic School is 95%, which is higher than the national average of 83%.
What sports does St. Matthew Catholic School offer?
St. Matthew Catholic School offers 10 interscholastic sports: Baseball, Basketball, Cheering, Cross Country, Football, Soccer, Softball, Track and Field, Volleyball and Wrestling. St. Matthew Catholic School is ranked as one of the top 20% of private schools in Indiana for most sports offered.
What is St. Matthew Catholic School's ranking?
St. Matthew Catholic School ranks among the top 20% of private schools in Indiana for: Largest student body, Most sports offered and Most extracurriculars offered.
When is the application deadline for St. Matthew Catholic School?
The application deadline for St. Matthew Catholic School is rolling (applications are reviewed as they are received year-round).
In what neighborhood is St. Matthew Catholic School located?
St. Matthew Catholic School is located in the Millersville neighborhood of Indianapolis, IN. There are 1 other private schools located in Millersville.
School Reviews
Endorse St. Matthew Catholic School. Endorsements should be a few sentences in length. Please include any comments on:
- Quality of academic programs, teachers, and facilities
- Availability of music, art, sports and other extracurricular activities
- Academic or athletic awards
Recent Articles

Transferring from Public to Private School Mid-Year: What to Expect
Considering a mid-year transfer from public to private school? Learn what to expect with admissions, academic placement, social adjustment, and financial aid to ensure a smooth transition.

A Guide to Day vs. Boarding School: Which Is Right for Your Family
Discover the key differences between day and boarding schools to determine the best fit for your child. Explore benefits, costs, lifestyle factors, and questions to help guide your family’s decision.

The A to Z of Private Schools 2025
Explore the A to Z of private schools in 2025—from admissions to tuition—offering parents and educators clear insights into today’s options.