Home > New York > Richmond County

Top 5 Best Staten Island Private High Schools (2025)

[+] Show Closed Private Schools in Staten Island, New York

Staten Island, New York Private Schools (Closed)

School

Location

Grades

Students

Eden Ii School (Closed 2025)

Special Education School

150 Granite Ave
Staten Island, NY 10303
(718) 816-1422

Grades: Inquire with school

| 99 students

Eltingville Lutheran School (Closed 2016)

(Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (formerly AELC, ALC, or LCA))

300 Genesee Avenue
Staten Island, NY 10312
(718) 356-7811

Grades: PK-7

| 127 students

Our Lady Of Mt Carmel-st Benedicta School (Closed 2024)

(Catholic)

285 Clove Rd
Staten Island, NY 10310
(718) 981-5131

Grades: PK-8

| 169 students

St. Adalbert School (Closed 2013)

(Catholic)

355 Morningstar Rd
Staten Island, NY 10303
(718) 442-2020

Grades: PK-8

| 217 students

St. Christopher School (Closed)

(Catholic)

15 Lisbon Place
Staten Island, NY 10306
(718) 351-0902

Grades: PK-8

| 259 students

St. Margaret Mary School (Closed 2010)

(Catholic)

1128 Olympia Blvd
Staten Island, NY 10306
(718) 351-4778

Grades: K-9

| 119 students

St. Mary's School (Closed 2008)

(Catholic)

1124 Bay St
Staten Island, NY 10305
(718) 447-1842

Grades: K-9

| 237 students

St. Paul's School (Closed 2008)

(Catholic)

129 Clinton Avenue
Staten Island, NY 10301
(718) 447-5774

Grades: NS-8

| 220 students

St. Rita School (Closed 2021)

(Catholic)

30 Wellbrook Ave
Staten Island, NY 10314
(718) 761-2504

Grades: PK-8

| 273 students

St. Sylvester School (Closed 2010)

(Catholic)

884 Targee St
Staten Island, NY 10304
(718) 442-4938

Grades: K-9

| 152 students

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top ranked private high schools in Staten Island, NY?

The private high schools in Staten Island, NY include St. Joseph By The Sea High School, Notre Dame Academy High School, and St. Peters Boys High School.

How many private high schools are located in Staten Island?

11 private high schools are located in Staten Island.

How diverse are private high schools in Staten Island?

Staten Island private high schools are approximately 15% minority students, which is lower than the New York private school average of 37%.

What percentage of private high schools are religiously affiliated in Staten Island?

82% of private high schools in Staten Island are religiously affiliated (most commonly Catholic and Jewish).

Which private high schools in Staten Island are often viewed compared to one another?

Recent Articles

June 05, 2025

Podcasts That Will Change the Way You Think About Education

This article highlights a curated selection of podcasts that offer thought-provoking discussions, expert insights, and innovative ideas on various aspects of education. From exploring new teaching methods and technologies to discussing policy changes and social issues, these podcasts provide a wealth of knowledge and inspiration for anyone interested in education. Each podcast is briefly described, highlighting its unique focus and tone.

June 04, 2025

For-profit vs. Not-for-profit Schools

This comprehensive guide explores the differences between for-profit and not-for-profit private schools, discussing their organizational structures, advantages, and key considerations for parents. It emphasizes that a school's success is determined by its educational quality and management rather than its profit status.

June 03, 2025

2023-24 Best SSAT Prep Courses Reviewed

This article reviews the top SSAT prep courses, including Test Innovators, Enrollment Management Association (EMA), Princeton Review, Ivy Global, and Kaplan. Each course is evaluated based on its price, in-person and online services, officially licensed materials, instant normative scoring, and free trial options. We'll dive into the features and benefits of each course, helping you understand which one best fits your student's needs and learning style.