Most Selective Private Schools in Indiana

All Schools
(64)
All Schools
(64)
 
High Schools
(23)
High Schools
(23)
 
Elementary Schools
(50)
Elementary Schools
(50)
 
Preschools
(46)
Preschools
(46)
 
The average private school acceptance rate in Indiana is approximately 89% per year (2021).
The most selective school in Indiana is currently Colonial Christian School, with an acceptance rate of 35%.
The most selective private schools are listed below (where sufficient data available).

Most Selective Private Schools in Indiana (2021)

  • School Acceptance Rate Grades Location
  • Rank: #11.
    Colonial Christian School
    Colonial Christian School Photo - Science lab demonstration with Mr. Abreu and Dr. Matzko.
    (Baptist)
    Acceptance Rate: 35%
    Grades: PK-128140 Union Chapel Rd
    Indianapolis, IN 46240
    (317) 253-0649

  • Rank: #2-32.-3.
    Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School
    Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School Photo
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 50%
    Grades: 9-122801 W 86th Street
    Indianapolis, IN 46268
    (317) 524-7050

  • Rank: #2-32.-3.
    Eman Schools
    (Islamic)
    Acceptance Rate: 50%
    Grades: PK-1211965 Allisonville Road
    Fishers, IN 46038
    (317) 845-9466

  • Rank: #4-54.-5.
    Fortune Academy (formerly The Hutson School)
    Fortune Academy (formerly The Hutson School) Photo - Multi-sensory math makes all the difference for our students.
    Special Education School
    Acceptance Rate: 60%
    Grades: 1-125626 Lawton Loop Dr.
    Indianapolis, IN 46216
    (317) 377-0544

  • Rank: #4-54.-5.
    The Oaks Academy
    The Oaks Academy Photo
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 60%
    Grades: PK-82301 N Park Ave
    Indianapolis, IN 46205
    (317) 931-3043

  • Rank: #6-76.-7.
    Culver Academies
    Culver Academies Photo
    Acceptance Rate: 65%
    Grades: 9-121300 Academy Rd
    Culver, IN 46511
    (574) 842-8300

  • Rank: #6-76.-7.
    Lutheran South Unity School
    Lutheran South Unity School Photo
    (Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 65%
    Grades: K-85401 S Calhoun St
    Fort Wayne, IN 46807
    (260) 744-0459

  • Rank: #88.
    Acacia Academy
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 70%
    Grades: K-8830 S Main St
    Kokomo, IN 46901
    (765) 457-5545

  • Rank: #99.
    Sandy Creek Christian Academy
    Sandy Creek Christian Academy Photo - Valentine Party
    (Pentecostal)
    Acceptance Rate: 75%
    Grades: K-125707 Sandy Creek Drive
    Seymour, IN 47274
    (812) 528-7770

  • Rank: #1010.
    Liberty Christian School
    Liberty Christian School Photo - 2013 Sectional Champs!
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 76%
    Grades: PK-122025 Hillcrest Drive
    Anderson, IN 46012
    (765) 623-4568

  • Rank: #11-1411.- 14.
    Central Christian Academy
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 80%
    Grades: NS-122565 Villa Ave
    Indianapolis, IN 46203
    (317) 788-1587

  • Rank: #11-1411.- 14.
    Horizon Christian School
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 80%
    Grades: NS-127702 Indian Lake Rd
    Indianapolis, IN 46236
    (317) 823-4538

  • Rank: #11-1411.- 14.
    St. St.anislaus School
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 80%
    Grades: PK-81506 Washington Street
    Michigan City, IN 46360
    (219) 872-2258

  • Rank: #11-1411.- 14.
    South Bend Junior Academy
    South Bend Junior Academy Photo
    (Seventh Day Adventist)
    Acceptance Rate: 80%
    Grades: K-91910 Altgeld Street
    South Bend, IN 46614
    (574) 287-3713

  • Rank: #1515.
    Cathedral High School
    Cathedral High School Photo - Cathedral High School's college-like campus sits on 40-acres of woods and rolling hills.
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 83%
    Grades: 9-125225 E 56th St
    Indianapolis, IN 46226
    (317) 542-1481

  • Rank: #16-1716.- 17.
    Traders Point Christian Schools
    Traders Point Christian Schools Photo - TPCS students get to explore theories and stretch their creativity in MakerSpace activities. The TPCS vision is to prepare and equip each student to reach their highest individual potential to impact the world for Christ.
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 85%
    Grades: NS-125608 Whitestown Parkway
    Whitestown, IN 46075
    (317) 360-0468

  • Rank: #16-1716.- 17.
    Woodburn Lutheran School
    Woodburn Lutheran School Photo - Woodburn Lutheran 2013 Chirstmas Play
    (Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 85%
    Grades: PK-84502 N State Road 101
    Woodburn, IN 46797
    (260) 632-5493

  • Rank: #1818.
    St. Lawrence Catholic School
    St. Lawrence Catholic School Photo - Working with our hands! Kindergarten is all about learning and having fun AT THE SAME TIME!
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 89%
    Grades: PK-86950 E 46th St
    Indianapolis, IN 46226
    (317) 543-4923

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.
    Bishop Chatard
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: 9-125885 Crittenden Avenue
    Indianapolis, IN 46220
    (317) 251-1451

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-127400 E State Blvd
    Fort Wayne, IN 46815
    (260) 493-7400

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.
    Calumet Christian Schools Inc
    (Baptist)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: K-12826 N. Harvey St.
    Griffith, IN 46319
    (219) 922-8428

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.
    Calvary Lutheran School
    Calvary Lutheran School Photo - Kids get to have hands' on experiences starting in Preschool!
    (Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-86111 Shelby Street
    Indianapolis, IN 46227
    (317) 783-2305

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.
    Christ The King Catholic School
    Christ The King Catholic School Photo - Our St. Patrick STEM Lab in use by our students during their middle school Technology/STEM class.
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: K-85858 N. Crittenden Ave
    Indianapolis, IN 46220
    (317) 257-9366

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.
    Covenant Christian High School
    Covenant Christian High School Photo - CCHS Campus
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: 9-127525 W 21st Street
    Indianapolis, IN 46214
    (317) 390-0202

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.
    Faith Christian Academy
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-81550 East State Rd 205 North
    Columbia City, IN 46725
    (219) 248-4872

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.
    Montessori Academy Of Valparaiso
    Montessori School
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-K505 Marquette St
    Valparaiso, IN 46383
    (219) 462-1932

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.
    Pope John Xxiii Elementary School
    Pope John Xxiii Elementary School Photo
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-6221 W State St
    Madison, IN 47250
    (812) 273-3957

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.
    St. John Lutheran School
    St. John Lutheran School Photo - Our 5th & 6th Grade classes enjoy Outdoor Education at Camp Lutherhaven!
    (Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: PK-8301 S Oak St
    Kendallville, IN 46755
    (260) 347-2444

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.
    Sycamore School
    Sycamore School Photo - Sycamore School in Indianapolis, Indiana
    Special Program Emphasis
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: NS-81750 W 64th Street
    Indianapolis, IN 46260
    (317) 202-2500

  • Rank: #19-3019.- 30.
    Zion Lutheran School
    Zion Lutheran School Photo
    (Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 90%
    Grades: NS-86513 W 300 S
    New Palestine, IN 46163
    (317) 861-4210

  • Rank: #31-4131.- 41.
    Bishop Noll Institute
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: 9-121519 Hoffman Street
    Hammond, IN 46327
    (219) 932-9058

  • Rank: #31-4131.- 41.
    Christ The King School
    (Roman Catholic)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-852473 State Road 933
    South Bend, IN 46637
    (574) 272-3922

  • Rank: #31-4131.- 41.
    Lakeland Christian Academy
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: 7-121093 S 250 E
    Winona Lake, IN 46590
    (574) 267-7265

  • Rank: #31-4131.- 41.
    Legacy Christian School
    Legacy Christian School Photo
    (Christian)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: PK-10470 Lakeview Drive
    Noblesville, IN 46060
    (317) 776-4186

  • Rank: #31-4131.- 41.
    Lutheran High School
    Lutheran High School Photo - LHS is a 1:1 school. Each student has his/her own Apple MacBook as part of the curriculum.
    (Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
    Acceptance Rate: 95%
    Grades: 9-125555 S Arlington Ave
    Indianapolis, IN 46237
    (317) 787-5474

Recent Articles
Marketing the small private school can be done affordably and effectively. We suggest five easy steps to make that happen.
Solid parent-teacher relationships have always been an important part of K-12 education. During this interminable pandemic, parent-teacher relationships have become even more important.
The COVID-19 pandemic has changed schools profoundly. It has affected teaching and activities. We look at these changes and how they impact our lives.