Top Erie County Private High Schools

All Schools
(92)
All Schools
(92)
 
High Schools
(40)
High Schools
(40)
 
Elementary Schools
(69)
Elementary Schools
(69)
 
Preschools
(57)
Preschools
(57)
 
Public Schools
(216)
For the 2021 school year, there are 40 top private high schools in Erie County, New York, serving 9,652 students.
Minority enrollment is 21% of the student body, and the student:teacher ratio is 8:1.
75% of schools are religiously affiliated (most commonly Roman Catholic and Christian).

Top Erie County Private High Schools (2021)

  • School Location Grades Students
  • 205 Bidwell Parkway
    Buffalo, NY 14222
    (716) 885-6780

    Grades: 9-12 | 172 students
  • Amherst Christian Academy
    Montessori School (Christian)
    2625 Tonawanda Creek Rd
    Buffalo, NY 14228
    (716) 689-9944

    Grades: PK-12 | 74 students
  • Baker Academy
    Special Education School (Roman Catholic)
    120 Alexander Ave
    Buffalo, NY 14211
    (716) 828-7955

    Grades: 1-9 | 66 students
  • Baker Hall School
    Special Education School
    777 Ridge Rd
    Buffalo, NY 14218
    (716) 828-9737

    Grades: 6-12 | 110 students
  • Baker Victory Services
    Special Education School (Roman Catholic)
    780 Ridge Rd
    Buffalo, NY 14218
    (716) 828-9636

    Grades: PK-12 | 355 students
  • 72 E Niagara St
    Tonawanda, NY 14150
    (716) 695-5334

    Grades: PK-12 | 23 students
  • Bishop Timon-st Jude High School
    All-boys (Roman Catholic)
    601 Mckinley Pkwy
    Buffalo, NY 14220
    (716) 826-3610

    Grades: 9-12 | 187 students
  • 434 Delaware Ave Ste 1
    Buffalo, NY 14202
    (716) 464-3244

    Grades: 9-12 | 10 students
  • Buffalo Academy Of The Sacred Heart
    All-girls (Roman Catholic)
    3860 Main Street
    Buffalo, NY 14226
    (716) 834-2101

    Grades: 9-12 | 400 students
  • Canisius High School
    All-boys (Roman Catholic)
    1180 Delaware Ave
    Buffalo, NY 14209
    (716) 882-0466

    Grades: 9-12 | 878 students
  • Cantalician Center For Learning
    Special Education School
    2049 George Urban Blvd.
    Depew, NY 14043
    (716) 901-8700

    Grades: PK-12 | 416 students
  • 39 Ohara Rd
    Tonawanda, NY 14150
    (716) 695-2600

    Grades: 9-12 | 259 students
  • Catholic Central School
    (Roman Catholic)
    201 Winston Rd
    Buffalo, NY 14216
    (716) 864-7325

    Grades: 6-9 | 94 students
  • 412 Center Rd
    Buffalo, NY 14224
    (716) 675-6545

    Grades: 3-12 | 18 students
  • 39 Academy St
    Buffalo, NY 14221
    (716) 634-4821

    Grades: NS-12 | 257 students
  • 182 Sobieski St
    Buffalo, NY 14212
    (716) 895-3318

    Grades: PK-11 | 295 students
  • Gateway Longview Lynde School
    Gateway Longview Lynde School Photo
    Special Education School
    6350 Main St
    Buffalo, NY 14221
    (716) 783-3100

    Grades: PK-12 | 177 students
  • The Gow School
    The Gow School Photo - Students outside of Main Building
    Special Education School
    2491 Emery Road
    South Wales, NY 14139
    (716) 652-3450

    Grades: 6-12 | 157 students
  • Holy Angels Academy
    Holy Angels Academy Photo - Donations by the seniors
    All-girls (Roman Catholic)
    24 Shoshone St
    Buffalo, NY 14214
    (716) 834-7120

    Grades: 9-12 | 208 students
  • Immaculata Academy
    Immaculata Academy Photo
    All-girls (Roman Catholic)
    5138 S Park Ave
    Hamburg, NY 14075
    (716) 649-6161

    Grades: 9-12 | 180 students
  • 411 J J Audubon Pkwy
    Buffalo, NY 14228
    (716) 568-0226

    Grades: PK-9 | 118 students
  • Mount Mercy Academy
    All-girls (Roman Catholic)
    88 Red Jacket Pkwy
    Buffalo, NY 14220
    (716) 825-8796

    Grades: 9-12 | 233 students
  • Mount St. Mary Academy
    Mount St. Mary Academy Photo - Mount St. Mary Academy, founded by the Sisters of St. Mary of Namur in 1927, is an all-girls Catholic college-preparatory high school located at 3756 Delaware Avenue in Kenmore. Mount St. Mary’s is consistently ranked among the top ten Western New York public and private high schools.
    All-girls (Roman Catholic)
    3756 Delaware Avenue
    Buffalo, NY 14217
    (716) 877-1358

    Grades: 9-12 | 332 students
  • Nardin Academy
    All-girls (Roman Catholic)
    135 Cleveland Ave
    Buffalo, NY 14222
    (716) 881-6262

    Grades: 9-12 | 538 students
  • Nazareth Lutheran School
    (Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
    265 Skillen St
    Buffalo, NY 14207
    (716) 876-7709

    Grades: K-9 | 26 students
  • 3325 Genesee St
    Buffalo, NY 14225
    (716) 632-6084

    Grades: NS-12 | 37 students
  • 80 Luksin Dr
    Tonawanda, NY 14150
    (716) 694-0071

    Grades: PK-12 | 41 students
  • 1250 Amherst St
    Buffalo, NY 14216
    (716) 332-6300

    Grades: 5-12 | 575 students
  • 5599 Camp Rd.
    Hamburg, NY 14075
    (716) 649-4974

    Grades: K-12 | 51 students
  • 3144 Abbott Rd
    Orchard Park, NY 14127
    (716) 824-8208

    Grades: K-9 | 249 students
  • 4625 Harlem Rd
    Buffalo, NY 14226
    (716) 839-1242

    Grades: PK-12 | 310 students
  • St. Francis High School
    All-boys (Roman Catholic)
    4129 Lake Shore Rd
    Athol Springs, NY 14010
    (716) 627-1200

    Grades: 9-12 | 536 students
  • St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute
    All-boys (Roman Catholic)
    845 Kenmore Ave
    Buffalo, NY 14223
    (716) 874-4024

    Grades: 9-12 | 725 students
  • St. Mary's School For The Deaf
    Special Education School
    2253 Main St
    Buffalo, NY 14214
    (716) 834-7200

    Grades: PK-12 | 109 students
  • St. Marys High School
    St. Marys High School Photo
    (Roman Catholic)
    142 Laverack Ave
    Lancaster, NY 14086
    (716) 683-4824

    Grades: 9-12 | 360 students
Recent Articles
Choosing a private school is a process with many parts to it. It also takes 18-24 months to complete. This collection of articles deals with the first part of the process in which you begin to look at private schools and what they offer.
Marketing the small private school can be done affordably and effectively. We suggest five easy steps to make that happen.
Solid parent-teacher relationships have always been an important part of K-12 education. During this interminable pandemic, parent-teacher relationships have become even more important.